20% OFF Start Challenge Code:
For traders seeking maximum profitability, the prop firm with the lowest spread is often one that provides direct access to raw spreads from liquidity providers, coupled with a transparent commission structure. While many forex prop firms like FTMO and The Funded Trader are known for competitive spreads, traders should also consider futures-focused firms. Futures prop firms, which connect traders to centralized exchanges like the CME, offer a different model where the bid-ask spread is determined by the open market, providing inherent transparency and often very tight pricing on high-volume contracts.
Table of Contents
- Understanding Spreads in Proprietary Trading
- What Determines a Prop Firm’s Spreads?
- Are “Zero Spread” Prop Firms a Reality?
- Comparing Spreads: Forex vs. Futures Prop Firms
- Top Contenders for Low Spreads: A Cost Comparison
- How Can You Find a Prop Firm’s Real Spreads?
- Why Low Spreads Are Critical for Certain Trading Strategies
- Beyond Spreads: What Other Costs Should You Consider?
- The Cointracts Advantage: Transparent Pricing in Futures Trading
- Your Checklist for Choosing a Low-Cost Prop Firm
Understanding Spreads in Proprietary Trading
In the world of trading, the spread is a fundamental concept that directly impacts your bottom line. It represents the difference between the bid price (the highest price a buyer is willing to pay for an asset) and the ask price (the lowest price a seller is willing to accept). This small difference is the primary way brokers and, by extension, many prop firms, make money. When you open a trade, you are effectively paying this spread as the initial cost of entry.
For a proprietary trader, minimizing this cost is paramount. Think of it as a hurdle your trade must overcome before it becomes profitable. A wider spread means the market must move further in your favor just for you to break even. This is especially true for short-term strategies like scalping or day trading, where traders enter and exit multiple positions throughout the day. Over dozens or hundreds of trades, even a fractional difference in the spread can accumulate into a significant amount, separating a profitable month from a losing one.
What Determines a Prop Firm’s Spreads?
The spreads you see on your trading platform are not arbitrary; they are the result of a chain of technological and financial relationships. Understanding these factors empowers you to ask the right questions and identify firms that genuinely offer competitive trading conditions.
The Broker and Liquidity Provider Connection
Most prop firms are not brokers themselves. They partner with one or more brokerage firms, which in turn source their pricing from liquidity providers (LPs)—large financial institutions like banks and hedge funds. The quality and depth of these LPs determine the “raw” spread. A prop firm that partners with a top-tier broker connected to a deep pool of LPs will inherently be able to offer tighter spreads, especially during volatile market conditions.
Raw Spreads vs. Markup: The Two Main Models
Proprietary firms generally use one of two models for their spreads. The first is a raw spread model, where the firm passes on the direct pricing from its liquidity provider and charges a separate, fixed commission per trade. This model is transparent and often preferred by experienced traders. The second is a markup model, where the firm adds a small amount to the raw spread. In this case, there might be no separate commission, as the firm’s revenue is built directly into the spread you trade on. Both can be low-cost, but the raw spread model provides greater clarity on your exact trading costs.
The Hidden Cost: How Commissions Factor In
A low or even “zero” spread is meaningless without considering the commission. A firm might advertise a 0.1-pip spread on EUR/USD but charge a $7 round-turn commission per lot. Another might offer a 0.8-pip spread with zero commission. In this scenario, the “zero commission” account is actually more expensive. To get a true sense of cost, you must always combine the spread and the commission to calculate the total cost of a round-trip trade.
Are “Zero Spread” Prop Firms a Reality?
The promise of a “zero spread” account is a powerful marketing tool, but it requires careful scrutiny. In reality, it is extremely rare to find a prop firm offering consistently zero spreads across all instruments and at all times. The bid and ask prices for an asset are almost never identical in a live market. When firms advertise this, it typically means one of a few things.
It could refer to spreads that can touch zero for a few moments on highly liquid pairs like EUR/USD during peak trading hours (like the London-New York overlap). Alternatively, it could be a feature of a raw spread account where the commission is the primary cost. Be wary of any firm that promises zero spreads and zero commissions, as this is not a sustainable business model and may indicate other hidden fees or poor execution quality.
Comparing Spreads: Forex vs. Futures Prop Firms
A trader’s experience with spreads can differ dramatically depending on the market they trade. The structure of forex markets versus futures markets creates distinct environments for pricing and transparency, which is a crucial factor when selecting a prop firm.
Decentralized Forex Markets and Variable Spreads
The foreign exchange market is decentralized, meaning trades occur over-the-counter (OTC) through a network of banks and brokers rather than a single, central location. This results in variable spreads. The pricing a forex prop firm can offer depends entirely on its specific liquidity providers. During news events or periods of low liquidity, these spreads can widen significantly and unpredictably, leading to slippage and higher-than-expected trading costs.
Centralized Futures Exchanges and Standardized Spreads
In contrast, futures contracts are traded on centralized and heavily regulated exchanges, such as the Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME). All participants see the same bid and ask prices from a central limit order book (CLOB). This creates a transparent and level playing field. The spread on a futures contract like the E-mini S&P 500 (ES) is simply the difference between the best bid and the best offer from thousands of market participants. For traders, this means no broker-side markup on the spread, providing a true reflection of market supply and demand. This structure is particularly advantageous for traders who value price transparency and consistent costs.
Top Contenders for Low Spreads: A Cost Comparison
To illustrate how costs can vary, here is a comparison of typical all-in costs for a standard lot trade on EUR/USD among popular forex prop firm models. This helps visualize the importance of looking beyond just the advertised spread.
| Prop Firm Model | Average Spread (EUR/USD) | Round-Turn Commission (per Lot) | Total Cost Per Lot |
|---|---|---|---|
| Raw Spread + Commission | 0.2 pips ($2) | $6.00 | $8.00 |
| Standard (Spread Markup) | 0.9 pips ($9) | $0.00 | $9.00 |
| Low-Cost Competitor | 0.1 pips ($1) | $7.00 | $8.00 |
| High Spread Model | 1.5 pips ($15) | $0.00 | $15.00 |
*Note: These are illustrative figures. Actual costs vary based on market conditions and the specific prop firm.
How Can You Find a Prop Firm’s Real Spreads?
Marketing materials can be misleading. To discover a firm’s true trading costs, you need to do some detective work. Relying solely on a website’s claims is not enough; proactive verification is key.
Checking the FAQ and Help Center
Start with the firm’s official documentation. A reputable company will often have a detailed FAQ page or help section that outlines its commission structure and provides information on typical spreads for major instruments. Look for transparency. If a firm is vague about its costs, it should be considered a red flag.
Utilizing Free Trials and Demo Accounts
The most effective method is to observe the spreads firsthand. Most prop firms offer free trials or demo accounts that run on the same live price feed as their funded accounts. Open a trial account, load the platform, and watch the spreads on your preferred instruments during different market sessions. Pay close attention to how spreads behave during high-impact news releases to gauge the quality of the firm’s liquidity.
Reading Trader Reviews and Community Feedback
Leverage the experience of others. Join trading communities on platforms like Discord, Telegram, or Reddit where funded traders discuss their experiences. Ask directly about spreads, commissions, and execution quality. Honest, unfiltered feedback from current users is an invaluable resource for vetting a prop firm’s claims.
Why Low Spreads Are Critical for Certain Trading Strategies
While all traders benefit from lower costs, for some strategies, tight spreads are not just a benefit—they are a prerequisite for survival. The viability of these high-frequency approaches hinges on minimizing transaction costs to capture small, fleeting market movements.
Scalping: The Ultimate Test of Tight Spreads
Scalpers aim to profit from very small price changes, often holding trades for only a few seconds or minutes. They may target profits of just a few pips per trade. If the spread on an instrument is 2 pips, a scalper must first see the market move 2 pips in their favor just to break even. This makes scalping on high-spread instruments practically impossible. Scalpers exclusively seek out environments with the tightest possible spreads and lowest commissions.
High-Frequency and Algorithmic Trading
Algorithmic trading systems execute a vast number of trades based on pre-programmed instructions. Because these strategies operate on statistical probabilities and execute at high speeds, transaction costs are a critical variable in their profitability models. A small increase in the average spread can completely invalidate an otherwise successful algorithm. Therefore, developers of these systems prioritize platforms and firms that guarantee consistently low execution costs.
Beyond Spreads: What Other Costs Should You Consider?
An obsessive focus on spreads can cause traders to overlook other significant costs associated with a prop firm. A holistic evaluation of all potential fees is necessary to understand the true cost of getting and staying funded.
Evaluation Fees and Resets
The most obvious upfront cost is the evaluation or challenge fee. This can range from under a hundred to several thousand dollars depending on the account size. Furthermore, if you breach a rule during the evaluation, most firms charge a “reset” fee to let you try again. These costs must be factored into your overall budget and risk management plan.
Data Fees and Platform Costs
Particularly in the world of futures trading, professional market data comes at a cost. While some prop firms absorb these fees, others pass them on to the trader, especially for live funded accounts. These monthly data fees can add up. Similarly, while many firms offer free platforms, some may require you to purchase a license for more advanced software like Jigsaw or Bookmap.
Withdrawal and Payout Fees
After all your hard work, you want to keep as much of your profit as possible. Investigate the firm’s withdrawal policies. Do they charge fees for payouts? Are there minimum withdrawal amounts? Do they support low-cost withdrawal methods like direct bank transfers, or are you forced to use higher-fee options? These “exit” costs are an important part of the equation.
The Cointracts Advantage: Transparent Pricing in Futures Trading
For traders who prioritize transparency and a level playing field, the futures market offers a compelling alternative to the often-opaque world of forex spreads. At Cointracts, we focus exclusively on futures trading, providing our traders with direct access to the pricing of centralized exchanges like the CME Group. This structure inherently solves many of the problems associated with variable spreads.
When you trade with a Cointracts funded account, you are not trading against a broker’s markup. The bid-ask spread you see on instruments like the E-mini S&P 500 (ES) or NASDAQ 100 (NQ) is the real-time, market-driven spread from the central limit order book. Your primary transaction costs are the exchange fees and a clear, competitive commission, with no hidden markups. This transparent model is ideal for serious traders who require precise cost calculation and a fair trading environment to execute their strategies effectively. By eliminating the variable of broker-side spread manipulation, our traders can focus entirely on what matters: reading the market.
Your Checklist for Choosing a Low-Cost Prop Firm
Selecting the right proprietary trading firm is a critical decision. To ensure you find one with a cost structure that aligns with your strategy, use this checklist to guide your research and decision-making process.
- Calculate All-In Costs: Don’t just look at the spread. Always add the round-turn commission to the average spread to find the true cost per trade.
- Verify with a Trial: Sign up for a free trial. Spend time on the platform during different market sessions to observe live spreads and execution speed.
- Distinguish Market Types: Understand if you are trading in a decentralized (Forex) or centralized (Futures) environment. Choose the one that best fits your need for transparency.
- Read the Fine Print: Scrutinize the firm’s policy on withdrawals, data fees, and platform costs. These ancillary fees can significantly impact your net profit.
- Seek Community Proof: Engage with other traders in online forums and groups to get unbiased feedback on a firm’s real-world trading conditions.
- Match Costs to Strategy: Ensure the firm’s cost structure is viable for your specific trading style. Scalpers and high-frequency traders need the absolute lowest costs, while swing traders may have more flexibility.
